Laws that were Egregious or Impossible

Galatians 3:18.

Below is a clear, historically grounded explanation of the kinds of laws that were:

  1. Egregious (shocking, offensive, or culturally impossible) for Gentile believers, and
  2. Impossible (or crushingly heavy) even for Jewish believers

…all presented in a way that fits Paul’s argument in Galatians.

Laws That Were Egregious to Gentile Believers

1. Circumcision

For Gentiles, circumcision was shocking, painful, and culturally humiliating.
Greco‑Roman culture valued the intact male body; circumcision was seen as mutilation.
To demand it as a requirement for salvation felt like:
“You must stop being who you are to belong to Christ.”

2. Food laws

Gentiles ate pork, shellfish, blood‑sausages, and meat from markets connected to temples.
Jewish dietary laws would have required them to abandon:

  • family meals
  • civic feasts
  • workplace banquets
  • community celebrations

It felt like social exile.

3. Sabbath restrictions

Gentiles had no weekly day of rest.
Roman society worked every day except festival days.
To stop working on the Sabbath could mean:

  • losing employment
  • offending patrons
  • appearing lazy or rebellious

It felt economically impossible.

4. Purity laws

Gentiles were suddenly told they were “unclean” for:

  • touching corpses
  • entering certain homes
  • eating certain foods
  • sexual practices common in their culture

It felt like being permanently contaminated.

5. Temple‑related laws

Gentiles had no access to the Jerusalem temple.
If salvation required temple rituals, they were excluded by geography and ethnicity.
It felt like:
“You can never fully belong.”

Laws That Were Impossible Even for Jewish Believers

1. Perfect obedience to all 613 commands

The Law required flawless obedience—
not just outward actions but inward motives.
Even the most devout Jew knew they failed daily.

2. Sacrificial system

The Law required:

  • continual sacrifices
  • perfect animals
  • priestly mediation
  • festival pilgrimages

Most Jews lived far from Jerusalem (including those in Galatia).
Keeping the sacrificial system perfectly was impossible.

3. Purity and impurity cycles

Jewish life was filled with unavoidable impurity:

  • childbirth
  • menstruation
  • touching the sick
  • touching the dead
  • mold in houses
  • bodily discharges

Remaining “clean” was practically impossible.

4. Festival requirements

The Law required Jews to travel to Jerusalem three times a year.
For Jews living in Asia Minor (like Galatia), this was:

  • expensive
  • dangerous
  • unrealistic

Most could not obey this command.

5. Covenant curses for failure

Deuteronomy 27–28 lists terrifying curses for disobedience.
Every Jew knew they had broken the Law.
The Law offered no power to obey—only penalties for failing.

Why Paul Brings This Up in Galatians

Paul’s point becomes crystal clear:

  • Gentiles could never bear the weight of the Law.
  • Jews had never been able to keep it perfectly.
  • Christ fulfilled the Law for both.

Therefore:

The inheritance cannot come by the Law.
It must come by promise.

Sources: Copilot, BibleHub.com

Ellicott's Commentary: https://amzn.to/43dEeiq
Shop using my affiliate link
I would love feedback. Drop a comment. Thanks.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Death Omen for Herod Agrippa I

Image
In Acts 12:23-24, God deals with Herod Agrippa I who was responsible for the death of Apostle James and the imprisonment of Apostle Peter. All of this was done to placate the Jews. I suggest you go back and listen to the entire study of Acts 12 on Spotify (Five Minutes in the Word)! I found it interesting that two historians have completely different versions of death of Agrippa. Josephus says that Agrippa saw an owl sitting over his head, which he recognized as a messenger of evil to him. Eusebius, quoting Josephus Eccl. Hist.,' 2. 10.), leaves out the owl, and says that Agrippa saw an angel sitting over his head, whom he recognized as the cause of his sufferings. (Pulpit Commentary) Jews believed that owls are bringing messages of bad news. They also believe that an angel is assigned to each person Again, this is interesting because Agrippa was a Jew!  Herod knew the word and worship of the living God. But he accepted idolatrous honors without rebuking the blasphemy. 
Read more

About the Book of Acts

Image
  I began the study of the Book of Acts on October 24, 2022. I'll be sharing some interesting tidbits I learned in my studies.  The Book of Acts is the activity of the Holy Spirit.  Jesus promised His Apostles that we would receive power after the Holy Spirit endues them.  The Holy Spirit came with power upon the believers in Jerusalem on the day of Pentecost. The Holy Spirit continued to guide and strengthen the church and its leaders throughout the events reported in the Acts.  He continues to guide and strengthen our lives and churches today. 
Read more

The Gift of Tongues at Pentecost

Image
Acts 2.  On the day of Pentecost, the rushing mighty wind and the tongues, as of fire, accompanied the true gift – being filled with the Holy Spirit .  In response to the filling of the Holy Spirit, those present (not only the twelve apostles) began to speak with other tongues. These were languages that they were never taught, and they spoke these languages, speaking as the Spirit gave them utterance. People from Galilee (Galileans) were known to be uncultured and poor speakers.   This was all the more reason to be impressed with their ability to speak eloquently in other languages. “Galileans had difficulty pronouncing gutturals and had the habit of swallowing syllables when speaking; so they were looked down upon by the people of Jerusalem as being provincial” (Longenecker). This makes me think of my Dad.  He had a speech impediment, until he began preaching!  When he got up to preach, his speech was excellent.  But, he still could not sing.  Th...
Read more